Bagel Guides

What Makes Montreal-Style Bagels Different?

Montreal-style sesame and poppy seed bagels
Sesame (“white”) and poppy (“black”) — the two classic Montreal bagels.

Ask anyone who grew up in Montreal and they’ll tell you: a Montreal bagel is not just a smaller New York bagel. It’s denser, sweeter, chewier and slightly smoky — and that comes down to a handful of traditional steps that have barely changed in generations.

1. A simpler dough — with no salt

The Montreal bagel dough contains malt and egg but traditionally no salt. At Old Bagel House we use the same simple ingredients our bakers learned at Montreal’s famous bakeries: water, yeast, flour, sugar, eggs and oil — no shortening.

The egg gives the crumb a richer, tighter texture, and the touch of sweetness in the dough sets up the flavour that the honey bath finishes.

2. Hand-rolled, one at a time

Every Montreal-style bagel is rolled by hand into a rope and closed into a ring. Hand-rolling gives each bagel its slightly irregular shape and a wider hole than a machine-made bagel — and a denser, chewier bite.

Old Bagel House baker holding freshly hand-rolled Montreal bagels
Every bagel at Old Bagel House is hand-rolled.

3. Boiled in honey water

Before baking, the bagels take a quick bath in honey-sweetened water. Boiling sets the crust and gives Montreal bagels their shiny, crunchy-sweet exterior — the reason a plain sesame bagel tastes so good with nothing on it at all.

“To be a real bagel you must be boiled then baked in a wood fired oven, that’s exactly what they do here.”

— Google review of Old Bagel House

4. Baked in a maple wood-fired oven

This is the step you can smell from the street. Montreal bagels are baked in a wood-burning brick oven — ours is fuelled by maple. Baking for 12 to 15 minutes in the wood fire gives the bagels a deep golden colour, a lightly smoky flavour and that perfect chewy texture.

Because they’re seeded generously before baking, the seeds toast in the fire too. Poppy seed was originally the standard topping; sesame became the favourite after a poppy seed shortage following World War II.

5. Montreal vs New York bagels

The two most famous bagel styles in North America are often compared. Here’s how they differ:

Montreal-style New York-style
Dough Malt and egg, traditionally no salt Salted, usually no egg
Boiling Honey-sweetened water Plain or malted water
Oven Wood-fired brick oven Conventional deck oven
Size & shape Smaller, thinner, bigger hole Larger, puffier, smaller hole
Texture Dense, chewy, crunchy-sweet crust Softer, fluffier, more bread-like
Classic toppings Sesame or poppy seed Everything, plain, many flavours

Love a larger, fluffier bagel? Try our Twister bagels — the dough is hand-twisted before the loop is closed, so it pulls apart in lovely little pieces.

6. How to enjoy a Montreal bagel

  • Warm and plain — straight out of the oven, the way Montrealers eat them.
  • With cream cheese — plain, flavoured or smoked salmon spread.
  • As a sandwich — from the classic lox and cream cheese to Montreal smoked meat.
  • By the dozen — Montreal bagels freeze well; slice before freezing and toast from frozen.

Where to find fresh Montreal-style bagels in Ontario

You don’t have to drive to Montreal. Old Bagel House bakes hand-rolled, honey-boiled, wood-fired bagels fresh every day in Mississauga, Dundas (Hamilton) and London, Ontario. Come in, grab whatever just came out of the oven, and taste the difference.

View Our Menu

Share:
Old bagel house

Old bagel house

Our bakers learned their craft at Montreal’s venerable bagel bakeries — Real Bagel, Fairmount and St.Viateur — and now bake authentic Montreal-style bagels fresh every day in Mississauga, Dundas and London, Ontario.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *